diff --git a/TShockAPI/Bouncer.cs b/TShockAPI/Bouncer.cs
index 8d3d7636..76ffc3cd 100644
--- a/TShockAPI/Bouncer.cs
+++ b/TShockAPI/Bouncer.cs
@@ -416,6 +416,18 @@ namespace TShockAPI
 				CanBeAddedWithoutHostile = false,
 				CanOnlyBeAppliedToSender = false
 			};
+			PlayerAddBuffWhitelist[BuffID.ShadowCandle] = new BuffLimit
+			{
+				MaxTicks = 2,
+				CanBeAddedWithoutHostile = true,
+				CanOnlyBeAppliedToSender = true
+			};
+			PlayerAddBuffWhitelist[BuffID.BrainOfConfusionBuff] = new BuffLimit
+			{
+				MaxTicks = 240,
+				CanBeAddedWithoutHostile = true,
+				CanOnlyBeAppliedToSender = true
+			};
 
 			#endregion Whitelist
 		}
@@ -1867,41 +1879,57 @@ namespace TShockAPI
 			int type = args.Type;
 			int time = args.Time;
 
+			void Reject(bool shouldResync = true)
+			{
+				args.Handled = true;
+
+				if (shouldResync)
+					args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, number: id);
+			}
+
 			if (id >= Main.maxPlayers)
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected player cap from {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: target ID out of bounds",
+					args.Player.Name, args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject(false);
 				return;
 			}
 
 			if (TShock.Players[id] == null)
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected null check from {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: target is null", args.Player.Name,
+					args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject(false);
 				return;
 			}
 
 			if (type >= Terraria.ID.BuffID.Count)
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected invalid buff type {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, "", id);
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: invalid buff type", args.Player.Name,
+					args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject(false);
 				return;
 			}
 
 			if (args.Player.IsBeingDisabled())
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected disabled from {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, "", id);
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: sender is being disabled",
+					args.Player.Name, args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject();
 				return;
 			}
 
 			if (args.Player.IsBouncerThrottled())
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected throttled from {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, "", id);
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: sender is being throttled",
+					args.Player.Name, args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject();
+
 				return;
 			}
 
@@ -1910,41 +1938,46 @@ namespace TShockAPI
 
 			if (!args.Player.IsInRange(targetPlayer.TileX, targetPlayer.TileY, 50))
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected range check from {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, "", id);
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: sender is not in range of target",
+					args.Player.Name, args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject();
 				return;
 			}
 
 			if (buffLimit == null)
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected non-whitelisted buff {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, "", id);
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: buff is not whitelisted",
+					args.Player.Name, args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject();
 				return;
 			}
 
 			if (buffLimit.CanOnlyBeAppliedToSender && id != args.Player.Index)
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected applied to non-sender from {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, "", id);
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: buff cannot be applied to non-senders",
+					args.Player.Name, args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject();
 				return;
 			}
 
 			if (!buffLimit.CanBeAddedWithoutHostile && !targetPlayer.TPlayer.hostile)
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected hostile/pvp from {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, "", id);
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: buff cannot be applied without pvp",
+					args.Player.Name, args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject();
 				return;
 			}
 
 			if (time <= 0 || time > buffLimit.MaxTicks)
 			{
-				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString("Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected time too long from {0}", args.Player.Name));
-				args.Player.SendData(PacketTypes.PlayerBuff, "", id);
-				args.Handled = true;
+				TShock.Log.ConsoleDebug(GetString(
+					"Bouncer / OnPlayerBuff rejected {0} ({1}) applying buff {2} to {3} for {4} ticks: buff cannot be applied for that long",
+					args.Player.Name, args.Player.Index, type, id, time));
+				Reject();
 				return;
 			}
 		}
diff --git a/docs/changelog.md b/docs/changelog.md
index bef17eca..35e8c596 100644
--- a/docs/changelog.md
+++ b/docs/changelog.md
@@ -79,6 +79,9 @@ Use past tense when adding new entries; sign your name off when you add or chang
 
 ## Upcoming changes
 * Updated the Utils.FindByIdOrName to follow same logic. Now fuzzy match fallback to `StartsWith` and then `Contains`. (@sgkoishi)
+* Added `ShadowCandle` and `BrainOfConfusionBuff` (BoC dodge buff) to the `PlayerAddBuffWhitelist` (@drunderscore)
+* Improved rejection message and code duplication in `OnPlayerBuff` (@drunderscore)
+  * This will make it so Bouncer rejections regarding `PlayerAddBuff` will now always include the sender index, buff type, receiver index, and time in ticks, allowing much faster triage of buff whitelist issues.
 
 ## TShock 5.1.3
 * Added support for Terraria 1.4.4.9 via OTAPI 3.1.20. (@SignatureBeef)